proftpd + mod_sql: solving “slow login” problem

I had a very annoying problem with proftpd, which seems a common one at first sight: slow login and the problem, that a lot of ftp clients out there have a low timeout setting configured. The problem is that googling “slow connection” or “slow login” in combination with “proftpd” led me in a totally wrong direction. A lot of people seem to have a problem with DNS lookups, which can be easily fixed by adding …

UseReverseDNS off

IdentLookups  off

… to the configuration file, to turn of any DNS lookups. But this did not change anything for me. Running a ftp client in debug mode it turned out, that the authorization itself took a very long time, which led to a timeout with most ftp clients:

air:~ harald$ ftp -d

Connected to
220 xxxxxxxxxx FTP Server
ftp_login: user `' pass `' host `'
Name ( 
---> USER harald
331 Password required for harald

The password was send, and than the ftp client had to wait 10 seconds and longer for a respone. Lot’s of ftp clients have a timeout of less than 10 seconds, which results in a timed out connection for such a long response time.

After googling for quite some time without finding anything useful on this topic — besides the DNS lookup problem — i delved deeper into to the proftpd documentation and found a howto which gave me some hints of how to speed up ftp login.

As it turned out the problem was my SQLAuthenticate directive, which i just copied from the example configuration file of mod_sql. The configuration was set to:

SQLAuthenticate users usersetThe problem with this configuration is, that the userset switch seems to be very, very expensive. I still don’t know, why this switch is set in the configuration — the documentation contains no useful examples of when to use / when to avoid this switch, but eventually i found a forum post of a proftpd maintainer, where he tells, that the userset switch is not necessary to be configured. After changing above configuration to …

SQLAuthenticate users… login is fast as hell. I’m still curious why the switch was there …